Saturday, March 2, 2013

Classmate Response: What Makes a Best Picture?

Many incredible infographics were presented in class this week. However, having just watched the 85th Academy Awards and being a huge fan of some recently released motion pictures, I was particularly drawn towards Stedman Tam's What Makes a Best Picture.


As soon as I saw the infographic, I immediately knew what it was about. If it wasn't the red curtain-like backdrop or film-strip graphics, then it was the text. The infographic title and date of award ceremony were very effective in their role of making the focus of the graphic explicit. Labels for each film strip also made it easy to realize the context for each set of sub-visualizations. 

The organization of the various visualizations was quite intuitive. Upon seeing the graphic divided in an even juxtaposition, I knew the nature of this work was comparative. By simply referring to the headings, I had no trouble navigating the graphic and understanding exactly what was being compared.

I admire the clever use of colours. In deciding to investigate the representational value of the palette, I was pleased to discover a great amount of attention to detail. In the Genre category, for instance, colours appear to have been based on the actual film genre (i.e. red for romance). The colours of films on the opposite side of the graphic matched this scheme. Furthermore, if we look at the Runtime and Rating Rank categories, we'll notice that the colour of horizontal bars grows in brightness as the length of the bar increases. This golden hue also happens to resemble that of the golden Oscar statuettes. 

To make a suggestion, I would encourage an alternate use of data visualization for the IMDB Rating Rank of 2013 films – something more visually discernable than a text-based list ordered by ranking. Perhaps a series of gold stars filled to depict the film's rating (not unlike the system used by IMDB). 

In any case, this is a lovely infographic which poses a popular question. However, rather than simply answering it, it provides the viewer with enough visually represented data to make it a pleasure to pursue. Bravo.